Telegraph article on Izzy Amaro (August 2022)

Aug 21, 2022 | 0 comments

‘Every time I close my eyes, he is with me’: a former nurse on life after a manslaughter conviction.

Isabel Amaro received a suspended sentence after a six-year-old boy died of sepsis in 2011. She describes what followed that terrible day.

Jack’s death, which occurred just 11 hours after he was admitted to the hospital, had devastating consequences for his family and sparked a legal case that lasted for a decade. The case revolved around the actions of his paediatrician, Dr Hadiza Bawa-Garba, and nurse Isabel Amaro. Both had previously unblemished careers in the medical profession but were charged with manslaughter by gross negligence.
Dr Bawa-Garba and Isabel Amaro were convicted in 2015 and given two-year suspended prison sentences, while a second nurse, Theresa Taylor, was cleared of charges. The verdict created controversy and protests among doctors who believed that Dr. Bawa-Garba had been made a scapegoat for systemic failures within the National Health Service (NHS). After public support and crowdfunding, Dr. Bawa-Garba’s medical license was eventually reinstated.
However, the focus of the article is on Isabel Amaro, who was largely overlooked in the aftermath of the case. Despite her involvement in Jack’s care, Amaro received minimal support, especially when compared to Dr. Bawa-Garba. She lost her job as an agency nurse shortly after Jack’s death, while Dr. Bawa-Garba continued working at the hospital for four more years. Amaro’s journey took a different trajectory, leading to a suspended nursing license and the loss of her career. She was unable to secure legal representation during her hearing in front of the Nursing and Midwifery Council’s Conduct and Competence Committee (CCC).
Amaro’s life spiralled into depression, and she made multiple suicide attempts. She was subjected to public abuse, received death threats, and lost most of her friends. She lives alone in a one-bedroom flat, grappling with her emotional turmoil and physical health issues. Isabel Amaro shares her story, expressing her remorse for Jack’s death and her wish to ease the family’s pain. She regrets her mistakes but feels she has been unfairly treated and unsupported compared to Dr Bawa-Garba.
The article highlights the stark disparity in support and treatment between doctors and nurses in cases like this, shedding light on the challenges nurses like Amaro face when involved in medical malpractice cases. It underscores the need for equal support and fair treatment within the healthcare profession, regardless of one’s role.
Related posts:
The NMC is still failing with FtP.

We ask, does it want to change, or is this lack of insight too ingrained in a process that is no longer fit for purpose?   PSA report is published This week’s annual report out by the Professional Standards Authority highlights that the NMC continues to fail...

Vassanta Suddock – a true  inspiration

Today I found out the sad news that Vassanta has died. I met Vassanta when I was going through my own Fitness to Practice process and it was she who inspired me to have the courage to appeal against my strike-off. She was tenacious, skilled and so knowledgeable in all...

Whistleblowing regulation event

Today I was delighted to be invited to speak at the Whistleblowers UK event looking at their plans for the Office for the Whistleblower. UK Parliament My session was part of the Health Round Table, alongside other eminent professionals including Dr Jenny Vaughan – an...

Bias in NMC referrals and the nurses most at risk.

Black and Asian nurses are more likely to face fitness to practise proceedings - and to have their cases dropped early. So what can be done to end the prejudice? by Nick Evans, health journalist 30 January 2023 vol 38, number 3, nursingstandard.com (paywall)  ...