Defamation of character – do I have a case?

Apr 19, 2021

It seems common sense that if someone during the FtP process has deliberately lied or caused harm to you that you should be able to prosecute them for defamation of character.

 

Unfortunately, there is an extremely old law, dating back to the days of William of Orange, that prevents anyone working for or giving witness to a public body being prosecuted in this way.

 

“Absolute privilege is a complete defence to an action for defamation in English law. If the defence of absolute privilege applies it is irrelevant that a defendant has acted with malice, knew information was false or acted solely to damage the reputation of the plaintiff.”

 

Vasanta Suddock is a nurse who managed to overturn a strike-off order in the High Court following her self-litigating. She overturned over 43 charges against her. She then went on to pursue the NMC in the courts for defamation. The judge made some very supportive comments but said until the absolute privilege law is changed there is nothing that can be done. She is trying to challenge this through the European Court of Human Rights. Read more about the case here.

 

Of course, we want those in public office to be able to speak freely without risk of prosecution, but this needs to be balanced with proportionality against fairness. The NMC has not, to date, pursued her to reclaim the costs but this is always a risk of registrants when they continue to pursue cases on the basis of defamation.


You can, however, look at civil actions around human rights, breaching privacy and the right to family life but we would recommend you get strong legal advice before looking at this – the NMC have much bigger legal teams and resources so you need to match that with relevant expertise.
Related posts:
Case study 22 – NMC must reform procedures

This midwife qualified in 2014 and began her career working at a Trust in North-East England working under the preceptorship program. Preceptorship enables newly qualified nurses and midwives to receive ongoing supervision as they enter the working profession to build...

Diary of a Registrant accused

This is a direct account from a member of NMCWatch who has consented for us to publish, but who wishes to remain anonymous. She had 27 charges against her, these were taken down to 10 at hearing and only 1 found proven. The whole process took over 3 years and the...

Letter to investigation of NMC culture & whistleblowing

NMCWatch and Midwives Haven have written a letter to the KC investigating the Nursing and Midwifery Council's (NMC) culture and whistleblowing. To summarise: we raise our concerns regarding the NMC's handling of investigations. We highlight the potential biases and...

The NMC is still failing with FtP.

We ask, does it want to change, or is this lack of insight too ingrained in a process that is no longer fit for purpose?   PSA report is published This week’s annual report out by the Professional Standards Authority highlights that the NMC continues to fail...